Uncle Sheldon INSURANCE
Cape May, New Jersey

Home Insurance in Cape May

Historic homes, summer rentals and quiet winters each leave their own gaps.

Sheldon Lavis

By Sheldon Lavis

Founder and Lead Agent

Cape May has been a National Historic Landmark district since the 1970s, and the city’s Historic Preservation Commission reviews most exterior work in the district. If a porch or trim on Hughes Street or Columbia Avenue gets damaged, it usually has to come back the way it was. That’s the starting point for insuring a home here.

Dwelling limits that are too low. This one shows up constantly. A Victorian should be insured for what restoration actually costs, with real wood trim and period details, not a builder-grade rebuild.

Not enough ordinance or law coverage. This helps pay the extra cost of rebuilding to code and to the commission’s standards. Many policies include only a small amount.

The wrong form for how you use the house. An HO-3 fits most homes you live in. Some fully restored homes can qualify for an HO-5, which covers your belongings more broadly. Condos in converted guest houses need an HO-6. And if you rent by the week in summer, a DP-3 landlord policy usually fits better than any homeowners form.

Winter vacancy. Plenty of homes from the historic district to the beach blocks near Poverty Beach sit empty from fall to spring. Vacancy wording and a water shutoff or leak monitor matter more here than in most towns.

Flood. Never part of a homeowners policy. Homes closer to the harbor and the beach should have a separate one.

We’re a friendly, honest broker that knows this town, the Victorians, the rentals and the newer homes near the harbor. We shop carriers that are comfortable with older homes and explain everything plainly, and working with us doesn’t cost you anything extra. It’s the same approach we take for homes along the coast, just with more gingerbread trim to account for.

Ready to Review Your Coverage?

Whether you're shopping for the first time or looking for better rates, our experts are here to help you find the right fit.