A lot of Colorado home policies now have a wind and hail deductible that’s separate from the regular one, and on mountain homes it’s usually figured as a percent of the home’s coverage amount instead of a flat dollar amount. Most people don’t look at it until after a storm, and then it’s the only number that matters.
The percent is based on your dwelling coverage, not the size of the claim. On a Vail home insured for $2,500,000, a 1% deductible is $25,000, 2% is $50,000 and 5% is $125,000. Compare that to a flat $5,000 or $10,000 deductible and you can see why you need to understand this before you pick. Some carriers only offer percentage deductibles in the mountains now, others still offer flat options for a higher premium.
Vail does get hail, but the bigger storms hit the Front Range and the plains east of Denver more often than the high valleys. Wind is more of an everyday issue in Vail. It can peel off roofing, drop trees on decks and push snow and ice around. That doesn’t mean you should go with the highest deductible, just that it’s a little different than Boulder. We explain how hail claims usually work in Boulder if you want to compare.
So how do you pick?
Start with what you can pay. Your deductible should be an amount you could pay tomorrow without having to sell anything. If $50,000 would hurt, then 2% on a $2.5 million home is too high no matter what it saves.
Look at the actual savings. Get quotes at two or three deductible levels. If going from 1% to 2% only saves a few hundred bucks a year but puts another $25,000 on you, that’s usually not worth it. If it saves a lot every year, it might be.
Think about your roof. A newer metal or impact resistant roof means fewer small claims, so a higher deductible can make more sense. An older roof is the opposite.
Think about how often you’re there. If it’s a second home that sits empty for weeks, damage can get worse before anyone sees it, so pick a deductible you’d actually be ok using.
If you own a condo or townhome, the HOA’s master policy probably has a wind and hail deductible of its own too, and sometimes it’s a big one. After a storm the HOA can pass part of that to each owner. Loss assessment coverage on your own policy helps with that, and our Vail condo coverage page explains how it works.
For single family homes, we quote multiple carriers on every Vail home we work on and show you the deductible options side by side, so you can see the real difference and not just the premium.